23 Comments

Elrond vs. Durin in the first round is brutal!!!

Expand full comment

true creation requires sacrifice 😅

Expand full comment

Ah and what a sacrifice it was😭🤣

Expand full comment

I felt the same way!

Expand full comment

I love the idea of book versus movie! Or how about doing all bad guys?

Expand full comment

Yeah, book vs. movie is pretty interesting to me, though I love that idea of all villains! haha

Expand full comment

Or good guys on one side and bad guys on the other so the final is good vs evil

Expand full comment

I think that's how it went last year, if I remember correctly.

Expand full comment

Ahh I don't think I was around for that one!

Expand full comment

Yeah, last year the regions were "Heroes of the Hobbit" and "Heroes of LOTR" on one side and "Villains of the Hobbit" and "Villains of LOTR" on the other! You can check out the bracket here (and follow the links at the bottom of each to track the progress OR just search this site for 'March Madness Champion' I think to skip to the end haha)

https://www.jrrjokien.com/i/142346886/jokien-with-tolkien-middle-earth-march-madness-tournament

Expand full comment

Either heroes one side and villains another or bracket where each book character initially goes against themselves in movie form

Expand full comment

Oh I like it just starting with all those matchups: take on your doppelganger and then face off against the stronger version of all the other characters haha

Expand full comment

Yes, exactly!!

Expand full comment

A favorite moments bracket would be so fun. Or best locations!

Also, Treebeard vs Pippin was so hard, why’d you do that 🤣

Expand full comment

Book vs movie characters is great, but I've been thinking about seeing slaughter next year in the form of making it a multiverse clash between LOTR and GoT!😁 I'm curious how badly the latter would be smashed in the votings... or would they?🤔

Expand full comment

I’m here for the all Silmarillion bracket! The Valar would make some interesting matchups. (Currently listening to Andy Serkis read the Simarillion for the second time, quite enjoyable.) I didn’t have to look anyone up! Had to make some guess for WoR though, because I have yet to see it.

Expand full comment

Loved this! it was pretty easy to vote. I bet you can guess at least one person i voted for based on my username alone.. ;-)

Expand full comment

Fun stuff

Expand full comment

This is such a fun idea! I can't wait to see how it rolls out. =D

Expand full comment

I'd love to see Books vs Movies!

Expand full comment

Definitely would enjoy pitting book versions of characters against the movie versions of themselves

Expand full comment

So fun!!

Expand full comment

Beren vs Túrin is brutal, my poor tragic dumpster fire! So excited to see how these matches shake out! And as for next year, I think an All Silmarillion bracket would be intensely amazing!

Expand full comment