11 Comments
User's avatar
Glori Writes's avatar

I still think Bill the Pony should be in the contest... but whatever I suppose

Expand full comment
Sarah May Grunwald's avatar

It is very rude he didn't make it through. But Galadriel from ROP is still on here? It just doesn't make sense.

Expand full comment
Tiffany Thornton's avatar

This is my thought exactly! How?

Expand full comment
Glori Writes's avatar

YES!

Expand full comment
Joanna Colclough's avatar

Ten points for “internecine”

Expand full comment
Elisabeth G. Biggs's avatar

First Faramir and Eowyn, now Beren v. Luthien?? The inter-relational conflict here is getting stronger...

Expand full comment
Casey Craigie's avatar

Luthien should win, Beren would want it that way.

Expand full comment
Tiffany Thornton's avatar

My thoughts exactly

Expand full comment
clar's avatar

Both were very unfair pairs to choose between, I might add!

Expand full comment
Tiffany Thornton's avatar

Love Eowyn, but Treebeard for the win!

Expand full comment
Allison McBain Hudson's avatar

For some reason, this poll only works on your site, not on Substack (it doesn't seem to recognise my login)... anyone else?

Expand full comment